Lost or Forgotten Oldie of the Day: 1956 The Platters – You’ll Never Know

1956 The Platters – You’ll Never Know 

Herb Reed founded the Platters and came up with the name for the singers based on the slang term disc jockeys used for records. He recruited Cornell Gunter as their lead singer.

Gaynel Hodge was the member who acted as their music director. Gaynel had been a member of the Turks, a group later known as The Hollywood Flames. Gaynel and another member of the Turks, Curtis Williams, had written Earth Angel with Jesse Belvin, and the song became a huge hit for the Penguins.

Gaynel’s brother Alex and Joe Jefferson rounded out the group.

In 1953, Tony Williams replaced Cornell as the lead singer of the group. Gaynel left the Platters and joined the West Coast doo-wop group the Flairs, and left them to join the Coasters in 1958. David Lynch joined the group.

By 1954, the band’s manager, songwriter Buck Ram, also replaced Alex with Paul Robi, and hired a woman, Zola Taylor, to replace Joe. The resulting lineup was responsible for most of the hit records the Platters had from 1955 to 1959. The group quickly had four top ten singles, including two (The Great Pretender and My Prayer) that topped the Hot 100 in 1956.

Their next single was a cover of a song that Alice Faye sang in the 1943 film Hello, Frisco, HelloYou’ll Never Know. Her version probably wasn’t even released on vinyl, but the song was popular enough that three versions charted in 1943: the #1 single by Dick Haymes, Frank Sinatra’s recording with the Bobby Tucker Singers that peaked at #2, and the near-instrumental version by Willie Kelly and his Orchestra that reached #6.

Rosemary Clooney and Harry James released another version of the song in 1953 that only reached #18, but her next outing made up for it when she recorded Hey There and the single topped the Hot 100.

Zola sang lead when the Platters released  You’ll Never Know in 1955. Their cover only reached #11 on the Hot 100.

Sonny Turner took over as the lead singer in the group in 1959, and their label, Mercury Records, refused to release any recordings that did not have Tony singing lead. The record company kept releasing older recordings the group had made until their contract with the group expired.

Numerous other members came and went, and before long, five distinct groups began touring that were using “The Platters” as at least part of their band’s name. That led to lawsuits and angry, hurt feelings for years until most of the members had died. There is still a group performing live as the Platters, but none of them were in the group prior to 1970.


My books are on sale on Amazon (or free with Kindle Unlimited) and contain a lot more Lost or Forgotten Oldies. You can visit my author page to see them and you can read them for free with Kindle Unlimited!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s